top of page

Construction: Why a Profitable Subcontractor Lost $118,500 in Cash

Profitable on Paper, Out of Cash

Construction | Illustrative case study

​

A bucket tells you how much water is left. It cannot tell you which hole is leaking.

A drywall subcontractor in the Denver area closed its year with $186,000 of reported profit. Its bank balance fell from $203,000 to $84,500, a decline of $118,500. A supplier wanted to discuss the account. The owner wanted to know where the cash went and which of two large jobs had made money.

​

The setup

​

The firm has 14 employees and approximately $2.6 million in annual revenue. Crews are paid weekly, materials are paid for on delivery, and customers are billed monthly. Payments often arrive much later. The books were kept on the cash basis. Materials were recorded in one account, without job numbers. Some change-order work began before the customer signed the price.

​

Where the cash went

​

The reported $186,000 profit was after $126,000 of loan payments had been recorded in the books. The cash movement can be stated without a table:

Starting point — reported net income: $186,000.

Less owner draws — $13,500 per month, or $162,000 for the year.

Less skid steer purchase — $95,000.

Less estimated income tax payments — $47,500.

Result — $118,500 decline in cash.

The three outflows total $304,500. Against the $186,000 starting figure, they explain the $118,500 decline in this simplified cash bridge. The immediate cash problem was the amount withdrawn and spent relative to reported earnings.

​

What the books got wrong

​

Two accounting issues changed the profit picture. First, loan principal is a reduction of debt, not an expense. Of the $126,000 in loan payments, $48,000 was interest and $78,000 was principal. Second, $58,000 of completed work had not been billed: $46,000 in unsigned Job 2 change orders and $12,000 from smaller jobs.

The $46,000 cannot simply be treated as earned revenue. Recognition depends on approval or an enforceable right to payment under the applicable revenue rules. The two preliminary calculations are:

If all $58,000 qualifies: $186,000 + $78,000 + $58,000 = $322,000.

If the unsigned $46,000 is excluded: $186,000 + $78,000 + $12,000 = $276,000.

Use $276,000 as the more conservative preliminary figure, or 10.4% of the $2.6 million revenue. Neither figure includes depreciation on the skid steer or adjustments for receivables and payables. These are first-pass calculations, not completed accrual financial statements.

 

Which job lost money

​

Direct margin is contract revenue less labor, materials, subcontractors, and other direct costs. Overhead is excluded. The job figures are stated separately so that each amount stays attached to the job it describes.

Job 1 — Office TI. Contract and billed revenue: $412,000. Materials: $186,500. Labor including payroll tax and insurance: $142,800. Subcontractors: $38,200. Other direct costs: $11,000. Total direct cost: $378,500. Direct margin: $33,500, or 8.1%.

Job 2 — Medical Suite B. Contract and billed revenue: $322,000. Materials: $164,200. Labor including payroll tax and insurance: $158,600. Subcontractors: $44,800. Other direct costs: $12,400. Total direct cost: $380,000. Direct margin: negative $58,000, or negative 18.0%.

Together, the two jobs billed $734,000 and incurred $758,500 in direct costs: materials of $350,700, labor of $301,400, subcontractors of $83,000, and other costs of $23,400. Their combined direct margin was negative $24,500, or negative 3.3%. Both jobs had been bid at a 15% target.

If Job 2 could bill and collect the $46,000 in unsigned change orders, its direct loss would narrow to $12,000, or about 3.3% of revised revenue. The two jobs together would then show a $21,500 direct margin, about 2.8% of revised revenue. That recovery remains uncertain.

​

When the warning would have appeared

​

A monthly company profit-and-loss statement reports company totals. It cannot isolate Job 2. Year-end statements arrive after the opportunity to correct the job has passed. A job-cost report would have shown Job 2 running over budget in month 3 of 9. A work-in-progress schedule would have identified the earned-versus-billed difference in month 6. A 13-week cash forecast could have identified the coming bank shortfall before the supplier called.

By month 3, Job 2 had spent $55,000 on labor against a $42,000 budget for that phase: 31% over budget with the job only one-third complete. That was a warning while six months remained to address labor, price change orders, or press for payment.

 

What the fix looks like

​

First, assign a job number and cost code to every material purchase, labor hour, and subcontractor invoice. Second, price change orders in writing before work begins. Third, prepare a monthly work-in-progress schedule comparing cost, percent complete, and billings. Fourth, use a 13-week cash forecast to guide owner draws. Fifth, revise the bid model using actual labor burden, job costs, and the cost of waiting for payment.

​

What this case shows

​

Profit and cash measure different things. A single materials account can conceal a losing job. Unsigned change orders create collection risk after the costs have already been paid. The transactions exist; management needs job numbers, cost codes, and regular reports to make them useful.

This is an illustrative scenario, not an actual client engagement or demonstrated client outcome. Whether the $46,000 in change orders can be collected is unresolved.

KT Bookkeeping & Accounting provides job costing, work-in-progress reporting, and cash forecasting for contractors. Schedule a consult with KT Bookkeeping and Accounting today.

 
 

See our Privacy Policy here

Welcome to our site. 

QuickBooks Certified ProAdvisor

Thanks for submitting!

©2026 by Kutegeneza Techne LLC

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page