top of page

Construction: Why a Profitable Subcontractor Lost $118,500 in Cash

Nov 6
5 min read

Updated: Nov 10

This is an illustrative scenario. Every name and figure is hypothetical. It shows a method. It is not a client result.

A bucket tells you how much water is left. It cannot tell you which hole is leaking.

A drywall subcontractor in the Denver area closed its year with $186,000 of profit on the books. The bank balance said otherwise. It fell from $203,000 to $84,500. That is $118,500 gone. A supplier had asked for a meeting about the account. The owner had two questions. Where did the cash go? Which of the two big jobs made money?

The setup

The firm has 14 employees and about $2.6 million in revenue. It pays its crews every week and pays for materials on delivery, but it bills once a month and then waits.

The wait is long. Billd's 2025 national subcontractor report puts it at 56 days from pay application to payment. The survey behind it reached more than 800 construction professionals in 2024. The same report found that 43% of subcontractors lack the working capital for unexpected costs. The Construction Financial Management Association reports that specialty trade contractors hold 22 days of cash on hand (FY2024 data, 1,558 companies, member-reported). A small firm likely holds less.

The books were kept on a cash-receipts-and-disbursements basis, with a significant classification error: loan principal was charged to expense. Whether the company qualifies to use the cash method for federal income tax depends on its circumstances and the applicable rules. All materials went into one account. There were no job numbers. Change orders were done when the field was told to proceed. Some were done before the customer signed. The 2026 bids were due. Priced the same way, they risked repeating the loss.

Where the cash went

The reported $186,000 surplus already reflects $126,000 of loan payments incorrectly charged to expense. It is a figure from the books as kept, not reliable GAAP net income. Assuming all other cash receipts and payments are reflected consistently, the following simplified bridge explains the bank movement.


Item

Amount

Reported surplus, as booked

+$186,000

Owner draws ($13,500 a month)

-$162,000

Skid steer purchase

-$95,000

Estimated income tax payments

-$47,500

Change in cash

-$118,500


The reported $186,000 surplus, less $304,500 of draws, equipment spending and estimated tax payments, reconciles to the $118,500 cash decline. The $78,000 of principal was already included in the booked surplus as an expense, so adding it back in this cash bridge would count it twice. This bridge explains the cash movement under the stated assumptions; it does not establish the company's operating cash flow under GAAP.

What the books got wrong

The books also misclassified principal payments. A separate question is whether unbilled work qualifies for revenue recognition.

Loan principal is not an expense. Of the $126,000 in payments, $48,000 was interest and $78,000 reduced the loan payable. Correcting this entry increases the profit figure by $78,000 before considering other adjustments. The cash payment itself does not change.

The job files identify $58,000 of performed but unbilled work: $46,000 in unsigned Job 2 change orders and $12,000 on smaller jobs. Unbilled work is not automatically recognizable revenue. Contract terms, enforceable rights, approval status, progress toward performance obligations and collectibility must be examined. The $46,000 remains disputed in this scenario.

ASC 606 may permit recognition of a contract modification before a formal signature in some circumstances, but it does not permit assuming every unsigned change order is earned revenue. The following amounts are illustrative sensitivity calculations, not a completed accrual-basis financial statement.



If all $58,000 qualifies

If only $12,000 qualifies

Book surplus, as recorded

$186,000

$186,000

Reverse expensed principal

+$78,000

+$78,000

Potential recognized unbilled revenue

+$58,000

+$12,000

Illustrative adjusted result

$322,000

$276,000


Use $276,000 only as a preliminary scenario, assuming the $12,000 is recognizable and the disputed $46,000 is not. The $322,000 scenario requires support for recognizing the additional $46,000; a customer signature alone does not settle every ASC 606 question. These figures are not verified accrual net income. Receivables, payables, retainage, depreciation, other accruals and tax-basis differences have not been reconciled. The 10.4% ratio is $276,000 divided by the illustrative $2.64 million receipts figure, not a validated accrual net margin.

Which job lost money

Direct margin is revenue less the labor, materials, subcontractors and other costs charged to the job. Overhead is not included.



Job 1: Office TI

Job 2: Medical Suite B

Both jobs

Billed revenue

$412,000

$322,000

$734,000

Materials

$186,500

$164,200

$350,700

Labor, with payroll tax and insurance

$142,800

$158,600

$301,400

Subcontractors

$38,200

$44,800

$83,000

Other direct costs

$11,000

$12,400

$23,400

Total job cost

$378,500

$380,000

$758,500

Direct margin

$33,500 (8.1%)

-$58,000 (-18.0%)

-$24,500 (-3.3%)


Job 1's billed-revenue direct margin is 8.1%. Job 2 has a $58,000 deficit against $322,000 billed, or 18.0%. Together the two jobs show a $24,500 deficit on billed revenue, although the owner targeted a 15% margin. These are job-level management calculations, not audited contract-profit figures.

One account hid this. All materials sat in a single line. Job 1's profit and Job 2's loss netted into one number.

Job 2 also had $46,000 of disputed change-order work that was never invoiced. If the entire $46,000 becomes enforceable, recognizable and collectible, its job-level deficit would fall to $12,000, or 3.3% of $368,000. The two jobs would then show $21,500 of combined direct margin, or about 2.8% of $780,000. Neither recovery nor recognition has been established.

When each report would have caught it


Report

What it shows

When Job 2 appears

Monthly profit and loss

Company totals

Never

Year-end statements

The same, once a year

After the job closes

Job cost report

Cost against budget, by job

Month 3 of 9

Work-in-progress schedule

Earned against billed, by job

Month 6

13-week cash forecast

Expected low point in the bank

Weeks before the supplier called


At month 3, Job 2 had spent $55,000 on labor against a budget of $42,000 for that phase. That is 31% over, with the job only one-third done. It was a warning, not yet a loss. Six months remained, which is enough time to price the change orders before the work, tighten the crew plan, or press for payment.

Job-cost reporting uses the same underlying invoices, payroll and contracts, but requires reliable job assignments, cost codes, progress estimates and billing records. Revenue-recognition and accrual adjustments may also be necessary; they cannot be inferred from job coding alone.

What the fix looks like

The fix follows an order. First, every material purchase, labor hour and subcontractor invoice gets a job number. Second, change orders are priced and documented before work starts, with contract approval and enforceable payment terms checked. Third, a work-in-progress schedule runs each month. It compares cost, estimated completion and billings for each job, applying the relevant revenue-recognition policy. Fourth, owner draws follow a 13-week cash forecast rather than the bank balance alone. Fifth, the bid model tests the financing cost of delayed payment using the firm's actual terms and cash needs.

Takeaway for Subcontractors

  • Profit and cash are different measurements. The books showed a $186,000 surplus after incorrectly expensing loan principal; the cash bridge then accounts for another $304,500 in draws, equipment purchases and estimated taxes.

  • Unsigned change orders create collection and revenue-recognition risks. Their treatment depends on enforceable contract rights and supporting evidence.

  • A single materials account hides the job that loses money.

  • The data already exists. What is missing is a job number on each transaction and a monthly total.

It shows how the method separates a timing problem from a pricing problem. It does not show a client result. Whether the $46,000 can be collected is not settled here.

This is an illustrative scenario. No actual client outcome has been demonstrated.

The case illustrates how job costing, work-in-progress reporting and cash forecasting can expose problems earlier. The month-3 warning is hypothetical; no actual KT client outcome is claimed.

Want to know what this looks like for your books? Start here.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

See our Privacy Policy here

Welcome to our site. 

QuickBooks Certified ProAdvisor

Thanks for submitting!

©2026 by Kutegeneza Techne LLC

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page